Roughly 800 children could lose their soccer fields after a majority of Fernandina Beach commissioners said the city can no longer afford to buy the Ybor Alvarez complex from its municipal airport.
Three commissioners opposed the purchase at a Wednesday, Nov. 4, workshop, first reported by the Fernandina Observer. They pointed to Amendment 3, the constitutional amendment Florida voters approved Tuesday, Nov. 3, which city officials estimate will eventually reduce Fernandina Beach's annual property tax revenue by approximately $3.3 million.
No formal vote was taken. Mayor James Antun concluded the discussion by saying staff had received its direction.
What the purchase would cost
Two independent appraisals have been substantially completed, according to contract airport manager Nathan Coyle. Preliminary valuations place the roughly 11.64-acre property between $2.8 million and $3.5 million.
Nassau County committed $1.75 million toward the acquisition in February 2024, according to the Observer's reporting. Even with that money, the city would need to cover an additional $1.05 million to $1.75 million for the land alone. Drainage work, improvements and parking would add more.
Commissioner Genece Minshew said Amendment 3 had fundamentally changed the city's financial outlook. She said committing millions to the property was unrealistic when the city faces millions of dollars in reduced tax revenue.
Antun agreed. His daughter plays soccer at the complex, but he said he did not see a path forward. Presiding over his final meeting as mayor, Antun blamed the previous commission for failing to complete the city-county partnership project. He separately blamed the current commission for firing a city manager, saying the city lacked leadership for nearly two years.
Vice Mayor Darron Ayscue disagreed with abandoning the acquisition before receiving the final appraisal. He said commissioners should have considered financing arrangements.
City Manager Sarah Campbell told commissioners in June that the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) had indicated the city would soon pay fair market rent for the fields. She estimated the annual lease cost at approximately $380,000. No lease has been finalized, and that figure remains an estimate.
If the city decides against acquiring the land, the FAA will want a timeline for returning the property to airport use, Coyle said.
The commission had been scheduled to review the completed appraisal package and a possible FAA release request at its Nov. 17 meeting.

.jpg)





