Genece Minshew will be Fernandina Beach's next mayor after defeating fellow City Commissioner Tim Poynter in the Nov. 3 election, 3,736 votes to 2,927.
Minshew captured 56.1% of the vote to Poynter's 43.9%, a margin of 809 votes, according to unofficial results reported by Nassau NewsLine. All results are preliminary. Provisional ballots had not been counted as of election night, and the Nassau County Canvassing Board must still certify the totals.
Minshew will be sworn in at the City Commission's organizational meeting Tuesday, Nov. 17, at 5 p.m. at City Hall, 204 Ash St. The mayor serves a two-year term.
"I am deeply honored and grateful for the confidence the citizens of Fernandina Beach have placed in me," Minshew said, according to the Fernandina Observer. She said she would focus on fiscal responsibility, transparency and working with fellow commissioners.
No public statement from Poynter appeared in available reports as of publication.
Poynter retains his Seat 3 on the commission. Under Fernandina Beach's election system, voters select the mayor from among sitting commissioners, and the runner-up becomes vice mayor.
When Minshew takes office, her Seat 2 becomes vacant. Under the city charter, the remaining commissioners will appoint a registered voter who lives within city limits to fill it, according to Nassau NewsLine.
Paid parking loomed over the race
Both candidates had championed downtown paid parking, a program that drew months of public opposition, the Fernandina Observer reported. An unsuccessful citizen recall effort collected more than 1,400 signatures seeking both commissioners' removal, but a Nassau County circuit judge blocked it in April 2026.
About 75% of voters approved a citizen-initiated ordinance on Aug. 18 requiring voter approval before the city could implement paid parking. Poynter then moved to terminate the city's parking contract, and the commission approved 4-1. He later reversed course, calling the move a "knee-jerk reaction," but Minshew refused to reopen the debate and helped defeat the reconsideration on a 2-2 tie.
School millage passes with wider margin
Nassau County voters renewed the school district's 1-mill property tax, 30,634 votes (62.2%) to 18,605 (37.8%). The tax funds additional teacher and staff pay, fine arts and athletics, and school safety. The renewal runs from July 1, 2027, through June 30, 2031.
Support grew from 2022, when voters first approved the tax with 53.35%.
Turnout and other results
Nearly 62% of Nassau County's 82,056 registered voters cast ballots on Nov. 3, totaling 50,767.
Debby Portier won the Group 2 seat on the Amelia Island Mosquito Control District board, 7,656 votes (59.8%) to 5,155 (40.2%) for Todd Nuckols.
Both Amelia Walk Community Development District races were decided by fewer than 20 votes. Incumbent David Swan held Seat 2 over William Knudsen by 16 votes, 538 to 522. Incumbent Jeffrey E. Robinson kept Seat 4 over Cathleen Rutsey by 13 votes, 544 to 531.
-3.jpeg)
.jpg)





